Home / Real cases / Smith & Nephew Medical Ltd

PHW · Warehousing · 2026-09-14

Smith & Nephew Medical Ltd fined £230,000 after a 1.2-tonne crate fell from a forklift and injured a delivery worker

Hull · Hull Crown Court

What happened

A 1.2-tonne crate containing an electron microscope fell from a forklift truck while being unloaded. The unloading operation had been inadequately assessed, planned and supervised, and the load was lifted improperly.

Injuries: Life-changing injuries to a delivery worker employed by a third-party company.

The breach

Section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974

The sentence

  • Fine: £230,000
  • Costs: £111,000
HSE inspector

“This case should serve as a reminder to the wider industry of the need to properly plan and supervise unloading operations...”

What would have prevented it

Properly assess, plan and supervise unloading operations, especially for non-standard loads.

How PHW helps

The machines, packs and quizzes that fit this kind of site.

Sector

Lorries at the door. Forklifts and reach trucks in the aisles.

View →
Machine

Counterbalance forklift

View →
Machine

Reach truck refresher training

View →
Safety pack

Workplace Transport Safety

View →
Quiz

Could you show who is authorised to drive each forklift and reach truck?

View →

Source: HSE press release, Crate falls from forklift truck and seriously injures worker