Home / Real cases / Metcalfe Fencing Contractors Ltd

PHW · Construction and civils · 2026-09-29

Metcalfe Fencing Contractors Ltd fined £22,000 after excavator slings tangled in a ladder during a lifting operation and a fencing employee fell about two metres, fracturing his spine

Holystone, North Tyneside · South Tyneside Magistrates Court

What happened

On 10 December 2024 a 23-year-old employee was working on a section of acoustic fencing, four metres tall and 265 metres long, at a site in North Tyneside between the A19, near Holystone, and a housing estate. During a lifting operation the slings of an excavator became tangled in the ladder he was using and it tipped. He fell approximately two metres to the ground. HSE found the company had failed to properly plan the lifting operation and the work at height activities.

Injuries: The employee suffered spinal fractures.

The breach

Section 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974

The sentence

  • Fine: £22,000
  • Costs: £5,327
  • Other sentence: The company pleaded guilty. HSE gives the company's address as The Annexe Heatherlands, Grantley, Ripon.
HSE inspector

“This particular incident was wholly avoidable.”

What would have prevented it

Plan lifting operations and work at height together, and use remote release clamps and tag-lines so nobody has to climb a ladder to free or guide a load.

How PHW helps

The machines, packs and quizzes that fit this kind of site.

Sector

Mini plant and Stihl saws: show who is trained, on the day

View →
Safety pack

Working at height

View →
Machine

Mini digger and 360 excavator training

View →
Quiz

Who is allowed to run your plant, and where is it written down?

View →

Source: HSE press release, Fencing company fined after employee fell from a ladder