Home / Real cases / Jim Yates & Sons Limited

PHW · Construction and civils · 2026-07-14

Jim Yates & Sons Limited fined £20,000 after a dumper truck overturned into an unprotected excavation

Ince (near Wigan) · Warrington Magistrates' Court

What happened

A worker reversing a one-tonne dumper truck on a construction site drove it into an unprotected excavation and the dumper overturned. The company had instructed workers not to wear seat belts while operating one-tonne dumper trucks. Operators routinely fastened the seat belt behind them and sat on top of it, which disabled the vehicle's seat belt warning system and gave the false impression that the restraint was being worn. The driver was not wearing a seat belt at the time of the incident.

Injuries: Crushing injuries including a broken foot and ankle.

The breach

Section 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974

The sentence

  • Fine: £20,000
  • Costs: £4,824
HSE inspector

“Incidents involving workplace transport continue to cause death and life-changing injuries every year, and overturning remains one of the biggest risks when using dumper trucks.”

What would have prevented it

Never instruct workers to defeat seatbelt safety systems on plant, and protect excavations from vehicle incursion.

How PHW helps

The machines, packs and quizzes that fit this kind of site.

Sector

Mini plant and Stihl saws: show who is trained, on the day

View →
Safety pack

Excavations and buried services

View →
Safety pack

Vehicle marshal (banksman and reversing)

View →
Machine

Site dumper training

View →
Quiz

Who is allowed to run your plant, and where is it written down?

View →

Source: HSE press release, Groundworks company fined after worker seriously injured when dumper truck overturned