Home / Real cases / Commercial Lines Limited (T/A HLN Supplies)

PHW · Manufacturing and engineering · 2026-03-26

Commercial Lines Limited (T/A HLN Supplies) fined £16,000 after two workers lost fingers in separate machinery incidents

Leeds, West Yorkshire · Leeds Magistrates' Court

What happened

Two workers sustained finger injuries in separate machinery incidents within ten days. One reached into a sanding machine ventilation port and contacted a rotating metal disk, while the other's hand contacted a table saw blade while cutting plastic strips.

Injuries: First worker: what was left of her middle finger was removed and another finger, seriously damaged, will also need to be amputated. Second worker: lost part of the index finger above the knuckle and had the top of his middle finger removed in surgery several days later.

The breach

Section 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 and Section 3(1) of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999

The sentence

  • Fine: £16,000
  • Costs: £6,534
HSE inspector

“For this company to have not one but two completely avoidable incidents in such a short time shows systemic health and safety failings.”

What would have prevented it

Adequate guarding, proper training, safe systems of work and a suitable risk assessment need to be in place for every machine, including small-material cutting jobs, so that one machine's failings do not repeat on another.

How PHW helps

The machines, packs and quizzes that fit this kind of site.

Sector

Whoever is free takes the forklift. Could you show who is trained?

View →
Quiz

Could you show an HSE inspector who is trained on your forklifts and grinders?

View →

Source: HSE press release, Plastics firm fined after two workers lose fingers in just ten days